Showing posts with label MLS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MLS. Show all posts

Monday, May 5, 2008

A Response: Top 10...Ways to Save Major League Soccer (Part 2)


Last week, I carried on the discussion started by The Sherm on Major League Soccer and its current status on the sports landscape. The title of The Sherm’s post was Top 10…Ways to Save Major League Soccer, and my immediate response was, well, soccer certainly doesn’t need “saving” in this country. Perhaps as little as seven or eight years ago that would have been the case, but it is not so now.

However, MLS is at what a lot of people see as a make or break juncture in its existence. David Beckham is in good form with the Los Angeles Galaxy and regularly drawing sell-out crowds. D.C. United just signed a front-of-jersey sponsorship deal with Volkswagen which will enable the team to rake in around $3.7 million annually and will make Volkswagen MLS’ major auto sponsor. These major steps forward must carry the league to the next plateau.

The Sherm’s Top 10 list was very interesting. For someone who has a familiarity with the game and the league but isn’t a die-hard like myself, some of the ideas were eye-opening, while others were downright implausible. Here is my response to his Top 10 and some of my ideas as well.

1. Reality TV show – This has already been done in a Spanish-language format. The show is called “Sueno MLS”, which translates to “MLS Dream.” While I think this is a good idea, you have to consider it this way. With MLS trying to gain credibility on the world stage (which many feel will attract more fans at home), how does it look if one of Chivas USA’s Starting XI won his spot through a reality show? A little “Mickey Mouse,” no?

2. Market Individual Players – Agreed here. MLS must do a better job of this. There are some very marketable, young American players in this league and you don’t really hear about anyone other than David Beckham. Some names: Jozy Altidore, Sacha Kljestan, Stuart Holden.

3. MLS teams vs. Premier League Teams – This has been tried and will continue into the foreseeable future. The problem here is that these are exhibition games and usually the Premier Leauge team is just starting their pre-season training. Plus, people come to the games to see the world-renown clubs and couldn't care less about the MLS team. It doesn’t do well for the league, even if the MLS team wins.

4. Bring Known Players to the League – Definitely a major focus of the league and something they should continue to pursue. The idea here is to get them while they can still play at a high level. At this point, a guy like Zinedine Zidane is 35…too old.

5. Bring a European-Based Team to MLS – Interesting theory, definitely displaying some “out of the box thinking” by The Sherm, but it would never work. Logistically it’s a nightmare. How many transatlantic flights would that team have to make?

6. Have a Community-Owned Team – While this probably won’t happen in the near future, the spirit of the idea is what’s important here. Get the fans involved! Make them feel like an important part of their clubs.

7. Make Soccer a One Day Event – This is very important. Other than ESPN’s Prime Time Thursday game, every MLS game should be played on Saturday night. Other than the odd baseball game here and there, Saturday night is the least congested sports night of the summer. Usually the Sunday afternoon and other mid-week games are very poorly attended.

8. Make Tickets Cheaper – When all teams are in their own stadiums, they will be better able to control prices. But teams like New York and New England, who pay handsomely just to use the football stadiums they play in, need to keep prices at a certain level so they don’t lose millions upon millions of dollars.

9. Player Meetings Before Games – Great idea here. A lot of teams are pimping out their players and should continue to do so.

10. Mic Up Players/Coaches/Refs – A very good idea, though ESPN usually overdoes this sort of thing and ruins the game. They can barely get sideline reporting right. I can’t tell you how many times they’ve gone to a useless report or interview and a goal has been scored or a penalty kick awarded. These moments are what make soccer the beautiful, tense game it is! 99% of a broadcast’s focus needs to be on the game and the game only. Look at telecasts from England, Spain, Italy. Nothing on the periphery. Just soccer, how it should be.


So there are my responses to The Sherm’s ideas. Here are two of mine, very quick.

Promote the U.S. Open Cup – And the crowd goes, “Huh?! What in God’s name is the U.S. Open Cup?” This is where I direct you to Wikipedia. Yes, MLS’ main focus should be its own league, but this tournament should be seen as a big asset. Every European league, and most leagues in the world, have “Cup Competitions” that take place during the season outside of league competition. The most well-known international competition is the UEFA Champions League, and the oldest domestic Cup Competition is England’s Football Association (FA) Cup. The U.S. Open Cup could really become soccer’s NCAA tournament. People in America love upsets and the U.S. Open Cup provides them.

Increase the Salary Cap – The league has seen marginal improvement of the quality of play over the last few years, but this has been hamstrung by the ridiculously low salary cap (around $2.3 million this year). Give MLS teams the resources to compete for players on the open market. Enable them to bring in young players in their primes, not just aging stars or unproven kids. Many players in Europe have expressed interest in coming to America (Thierry Henry and Didier Drogba among them), but the money keeps many of them away.

Sorry for the long post. With the Rangers eliminated from the playoffs, you can expect continuing soccer talk from me on the blog in the future. Til then, happy freaking!

Thursday, May 1, 2008

A response: Top 10...Ways to Save MLS (Part 1)


Above: Toronto FC's home stadium, BMO Field, packed to the rafters. Toronto sells out every home game and when the home team scores, the atmosphere is akin to a Premier League game. No joke.


My esteemed colleague The Sherm posted some very interesting ideas in his first Top 10 posting on how to save America's fledgling soccer league, MLS. I'm here to tell you that MLS certainly does not need "saving."

Now, does MLS need to get its act together and capitalize on the burst of popularity of soccer in this country that has been going on basically since the U.S. National Team's storied 2002 World Cup run to the Quarterfinals? A burst which has been bolstered by a growing immigrant population that is largely Hispanic and soccer-mad? Absolutely. But, it has already taken steps to do that. Growth has been slow and steady, and that is exactly what MLS Commissioner Don Garber wants.

In 2007, MLS instituted its "Game First" initiatives. This included improving everything from pre-game presentation (teams walking on to the pitch side-by-side in single files, no flashy introductions, to a league anthem), to team images (no more sponsorship on uniforms unless it is front-of-jersey sponsorship, i.e. no more ridiculous looking SPRITE logo on the New England Revolution's shorts) to monitoring of referees to make sure the game is called consistently. The goal of "Game First" was to make MLS look more traditional. To get it in line with the world's top leagues. It was designed to bring in more traditional fans, rather than cater to the typical American fan or the soccer mom and family crowd. To some extent, it has worked.

The other alteration that the league made was to its salary structure, by adding the Designated Player rule (the Beckham Rule, as it were), enabling teams to bring in one player at a high salary but only have a fraction of it count against the salary cap. Since the institution of the rule, world-renowned players such as David Beckham, Juan Pablo Angel, Cuauhtemoc Blanco and Claudio Lopez have brought some credibility to the league.

Another sign that the league is moving in the right direction is the recent trend of expansion. Seattle will get an MLS team in 2009 and already has sold 12,000 season tickets (years ago, 12,000 was some teams' average attendance). Philadelphia will play in 2010 and have plans to build an 18,000 seat stadium which will probably be sold out for every home game.

MLS, in its teen years (2008 marks the league's 13th season), is still going through puberty however. The Kansas City Wizards and the expansion San Jose Earthquakes play their home games in former minor league baseball stadiums. Teams like the New York Red Bulls, Real Salt Lake and New England Revolution are using football stadiums and fans often have to deal with the aesthetic nightmare that is playing soccer on a field marked for American football (though NY and RSL have soccer-specific stadiums currently under construction...RSL's opens later this year, NY's sometime in 2009). The salary cap stands at a paltry $2.3 million, hamstringing every team in terms of depth and the ability to bring in more than one premier player. Often, people around the world, especially in elitist Europe look at MLS as a Mickey Mouse league. It has done well to fight that perception, and certainly the improved quality of play says otherwise, but it still has quite a way to go.

In Part 2 of this post, I'll respond directly to The Sherm's Top 10 and also list my ideas for how to market the league. One thing is for sure, though. American soccer isn't going anywhere.

Click for Part 2...

(Click The Sports Freakers for more good stuff)

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Top 10...Ways to save Major League Soccer (MLS)


So a few weeks ago, I was called upon to come up with ideas to save Major League Soccer. Why not take my ideas and post them. Please note that 90% of these ideas are unrealistic and downright dumb.


1) Reality Tv Show- Soccer players vie for an MLS contract. Series of skill tests. Bring on MLS stars to teach the players.

2) Market individual platers-Except for David Beckham, no one really knows any other players. Young stars like Jozy Altidore and Taylor Twellman aren't known outside of the hardcore fan

3) Have an MLS team face a Premier League team- It can be a three-game series or just one game. But putting MLS against Man U, Arsenal, etc. would bring some credibility

4) Bring known players into MLS- Theirry Henry, Zidane, Ronaldinho, C. Ronaldo, Droga, Adebayor are all big stars around the world. The first four are very marketable. Billboards, player interviews, etc. To follow along with this, utilize blogs, television, radio as ways of getting their name out. If Beckham can double his team's ticket revenue from one year, imagine what bringing more players in can do.

5) Bring a European team into the MLS- Most likely make it an expansion team, but imagine having a small team from England competing in the MLS? It would definitely bring International exposure and bring more of an "Us against them" mentality.

6) Have a community-owned team- Currently on the Internet, a community of people literally donated money to a website and bought a team. The website votes on lineups, transactions, etc. http://www.myfootballclub.co.uk/. Even if a community can't own a team, I think having the fans vote for lineups and decisions would bring much more involvement.

7) Make soccer a one-day event- They spread the games out way too much. If you want to do a gimmicky thing and have a Thursday night special every few weeks, fine. But people are confused with when games are.

8) Make games cheaper- There's plenty of empty seats in stadiums. Figure out what seats are consistently empty and slash those ticket prices. I'd rather 0 people sit in the upper deck at $30 a seat than 10 people sit in the Upper Deck at $10 a seat.

9) Talk to players before games- Pick two players a game and have them sign autographs in the parking lot or by the stadium for a 1/2 hour before games. How many times can a sport say they do that?

10) Mic up the players/coaches/referee- AFL(Arena Football) does this and it helped them immensely. Have the viewer feel like he is in the game.



Site Stats